| Best New Comedy Show 2009 | Cougar Town |
| Best New Drama Series 2009 | The Good Wife |
| Best Show of the Old Season (2008-2009) | The Big Bang Theory |
| Biggest Disappointment | Stargate Universe |
| Best Actor | Jim Parsons (The Big Bang Theory) |
| Best Actress | Julianna Marguiles (The Good Wife) |
| Best Guest Actor | – |
| Best Guest Actress | – |
| Best Episode | Supernatural “Changing Channels” |
| Best Joke | – |
| Best Quote | – |
| Best Scene | – |
| Best U-Turn | White Collar, last scene this year |
| Stupidiest Storyline | Bones episode as Avatar advertisment |
| Biggest Mistake | Cameron leaving House M.D. |
| Most Prominent Characteristic | fewer real opening credits |
| Best Opening Credit | True Blood |
| Best Score | – |
| Guilty Pleasure | Gossip Girl |
| Best Music Selection | – |
| Best Internet Show | The Guild |
| Biggest Anticipation 2010 | Chuck Season 3 |